The average cost for renters insurance in Wyoming is low; at $XXX, it is lower than the national average cost value. Wyoming is ranked 38 out of 52 on the list of the average renter's insurance cost value per state. Although rents are cheap in Wyoming, about 24% of renters spend above 30% of their annual income on rents and utilities. That leaves little money for other things, and renters insurance may seem out of their budget. But renters insurance in Wyoming is not expensive; the average monthly rate stands at $XX. The average cost of renters insurance may vary from one city to another. The city with the most expensive renters insurance in Wyoming is Evansville, with an average annual premium of about $231. Lusk, Glenrock and Afton are also a bit on the high side. On the other hand, people living in cities like Douglas, Newcastle, Rawlins and Jacksons pay lesser for renters insurance. The city with the cheapest renters insurance is Douglas, with an annual average premium of about $192, about 5.1% lower than the states average.