MetLife isn’t the only renters insurance provider on the market, so here are a couple of competitors which you can get a quote from and compare to MetLife renters insurance costs. State Farm, investopedia’s “best overall” renters insurance provider, and has the largest difference in price to that of MetLife, offers nationwide coverage from $8 per month, and has customizable policy options. State Farm offers Multipolicy discounts, and like MetLife they offer discounts for installing a home security system. Nationwide has similar coverage options to MetLife, and has the smallest difference in price, with the monthly premiums being similar to MetLife. With Nationwide you can also add on coverage for valuables and collectibles, earthquakes, water damage, and theft protection for personal belongings that are stored in a vehicle, trailer, or watercraft.